When most people think of the US Virgin Islands, they naturally think of St. Croix and St. Thomas. These two islands are the most popular destinations in the chain, but which one should you choose for your vacation? Let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of each island to help you make a decision. I hope this debate on St. Croix vs St. Thomas will help you make your final decision.

St Croix vs St Thomas: Pros of St. Croix Island

St. Croix is a gorgeous island with a lot to offer tourists and residents alike. Here are some of the big pros of St. Croix:

#1 Absolutely beautiful beaches

St. Croix, one of the U.S. Virgin Islands, is home to some of the most beautiful beaches in the Caribbean. The island’s east coast is dotted with secluded coves and sandy bays, while its west coast features dramatic cliffs and turquoise waters. Visitors can find pristine beaches to suit any taste in St. Croix. For those looking to escape the crowds, Sandy Point National Wildlife Refuge is a must-see. This seven-mile stretch of beach is relatively undeveloped and offers stunning views of the nearby coral reef. Fishermen and nature enthusiasts will also enjoy a visit to Buck Island Reef National Monument, where they can hike to pristine beaches and snorkel in crystal-clear waters. No matter what your interests are, you’re sure to find a beach on St. Croix that’s perfect for you.

St. Croix Beach

#2 Incredible food

St. Croix Island is home to some of the best food in the world. From savoury dishes to sweet desserts, there is something for everyone to enjoy. The island’s cuisine is a reflection of its diverse culture and history, with influences from Africa, Europe, and the Americas. St. Croix is also known for its freshest seafood, which is served in a variety of ways. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, you’ll be able to find it on St. Croix Island. So come hungry and enjoy all that this culinary destination has to offer!

#3 Great nightlife scene

St. Croix Island offers a wide variety of nightlife options to suit any taste. Whether you’re looking for a quiet evening at one of the many bars and restaurants or a lively night out at one of the clubs, you’ll find what you’re looking for on St. Croix Island. There are also many cultural events and festivals that take place on the island, so there’s always something going on. And if you’re looking for something truly unique, you can check out one of the many “glow-in-the-dark” beaches that are found on St. Croix Island. With so much to do, you’re sure to have a great time on St. Croix Island!

nightlife st croix

#4 Awesome Shopping

Shopping is awesome, especially if you love designer labels and Duty-Free prices!

There are many reasons why shopping is awesome on St. Croix Island. The island has a diverse range of shops and businesses, so you can find just about anything you need. There are also plenty of great deals to be found, especially if you know where to look. And the island’s convenient location means that you can easily get to and from your favourite shops.

One of the best things about shopping on St. Croix Island is the variety of shops and businesses. Whether you’re looking for a new outfit, a gift for a friend, or just some everyday supplies, you’re sure to find what you’re looking for. There’s something for everyone on St. Croix Island, so you’re sure to find exactly what you need.

Another great thing about shopping on St. Croix Island is the deals. With so many businesses competing for your business, there are always great deals to be found. Whether you’re looking for sales, coupons, or discounts, you’re sure to save money when you shop on St. Croix Island.

Finally, the island’s convenient location makes it easy to get to and from your favourite shops. 

shopping st croix

#5 Lush rainforests

St. Croix Island is home to some of the lushest rainforests in the world. The island’s unique climate and geography provide the perfect conditions for these lush forests to thrive. The average temperature on St. Croix Island is a balmy 80 degrees Fahrenheit, and the island receives an average of 200 inches of rainfall each year. This combination of warm temperatures and high rainfall creates an environment that is perfect for rainforests. 

The dense network of trees and plants on St. Croix Island helps to regulate the climate, prevent soil erosion, and provide homes for a diverse array of wildlife. In addition, the rainforests of St. Croix Island are home to some of the tallest trees in the world, including the redwood and douglas fir. These towering trees provide shade and shelter for the smaller plants and animals that live beneath them. The rainforests of St. Croix Island are truly a sight to behold, and they play an important role in maintaining the health of the planet.

Lush Rainforests - St. Croix

#6 Rich history & culture

St. Croix Island is a small, remote island with a rich history and culture. The island was first settled by the French in the early 16th century, and it remained an important French colony for over 150 years. During this time, the island was a thriving centre of trade and commerce, and it was also the site of many important historical events. In 1733, for example, St. Croix Island was the site of the first formal meeting between the French and English representatives who negotiated the Treaty of Paris. Today, St. Croix Island is home to a small population of people who still maintain many of the island’s French traditions. The island is also a popular tourist destination, and visitors can enjoy its pristine beaches, lush rainforests, and historic sites.

#7 Natural beauty

St. Croix Island is a small island located in the U.S. Virgin Islands. The island is well known for its natural beauty, which includes white sand beaches, turquoise waters, and lush vegetation. One of the most popular attractions on the island is Buck Island National Wildlife Refuge, which is home to thousands of nesting birds and turtles. The island also has a number of historical sites, including Fort Christiansvaern, which was built by the Danish in the 17th century. St. Croix Island is a popular destination for tourists from all over the world and is an excellent place to enjoy the beauty of nature.

#8 Incredibly friendly and welcoming people

The people of St. Croix Island are some of the friendliest and most welcoming you will ever meet. No matter where you are from or what your background is, you will always feel at home on this beautiful island. The locals are always happy to help with directions or recommendations for activities and restaurants. They will go out of their way to make sure you have a wonderful experience on the island. In addition, the people of St. Croix are very proud of their culture and heritage. You will often find them sharing stories about the island’s history and traditions. They are also happy to share their knowledge about the island’s ecology and wildlife. 

St Croix vs St Thomas: Cons of St. Croix Island

There are a few potential downsides to consider before booking a trip to St. Croix Island. 

#1 Cost

The cost of living on the island can be prohibitive for some visitors. Most accommodation options are expensive, and dining out can also be costly. In addition, many activities such as snorkelling and scuba diving come with an additional price tag. As a result, travellers wanting to experience all that St. Croix has to offer may need to budget carefully in order to avoid breaking the bank. St. Croix is located quite far from other popular tourist destinations in the region, so getting there may require an additional flight or ferry ride. 

Cost - St. Croix

#2 Weather

St. Croix is a beautiful island located in the Caribbean Sea. The weather is one of the most unpredictable things about the island. It is not uncommon for the weather to change rapidly, without any warning whatsoever. This can be frustrating for visitors who are not used to such extreme changes in temperature and humidity. The best way to deal with the unpredictable weather on St. Croix is to be prepared for anything. Pack light clothing that can be layered, as well as sturdy shoes that can handle wet and slippery conditions. And always have a plan B in case your original plans are thwarted by a sudden downpour or another unforeseen weather event. With a little preparation, you can make the most of your time on this stunning island, even if the weather doesn’t cooperate.

#3 Limited Job Market

St. Croix Island is a beautiful place to live, but it can be difficult to find employment. The island is small and there is a limited number of businesses. Many of the businesses are seasonal, so they only hire workers for a few months out of the year. There are also a limited number of jobs in the service industry, so competition for these positions can be high. However, there are still ways to find work on the island. Local newspapers and websites often have job listings, and there are typically hiring fairs held a few times each year. With a little effort, you should be able to find employment on St. Croix Island.

st croix job market

#4 Crowded Beaches

The beaches of St. Croix Island are undeniably beautiful, but they can also be quite crowded. The limited amount of space on the island overall means that there aren’t many places to go if you’re looking for a quiet spot to relax. Even the more secluded beaches tend to have quite a few people on them. If you’re looking to avoid the crowds, your best bet is to visit one of the smaller islands in the area. There are plenty of options, and you’re sure to find a place that suits your needs. Just be sure to do your research before you go, so that you know what to expect.

St Croix vs St Thomas: Pros of St. Thomas Island

#1 Perfect weather all year round

St. Thomas is a paradise for those who love sunny weather. The island has an average temperature of 27 degrees Celsius, with very little variation throughout the year. December and January are the coolest months, while August is typically the hottest. However, even during the hottest months, the temperature rarely rises above 32 degrees. St. Thomas is also blessed with relatively low humidity levels, making it a comfortable place to live or visit all year round. In addition, the island experiences very little rainfall, so you can always count on there being plenty of sunshine. 

#2 Gorgeous natural scenery

St. Thomas is a small island in the Caribbean Sea that is part of the United States Virgin Islands. The island has a population of about 54,000 people and is a popular tourist destination. St. Thomas is known for its tropical climate, beaches, and snorkeling. The island also has beautiful natural scenery, including rainforests, mountains, and cliffs. visitors can enjoy hiking, biking, and birdwatching in the island’s parks and nature reserves. St. Thomas is also home to many historical sites, including Fort Christian, which was built in 1672. The island’s reefs are home to a variety of marine life, making it a popular destination for scuba diving and snorkeling. Visitors can also take boat tours to see the island’s wildlife up close.

natural scenery st thomas

#3 Diversity 

There’s Something For Everyone: From world-class shopping and dining to outdoor adventures and historical sites, St. Thomas has something to offer everyone. Families will love exploring places like Coral World Ocean Park and Megan’s Bay, while

#4 Rich History

Few Caribbean islands can match the rich history of St. Thomas. The island has been inhabited for thousands of years, and its unique position at the crossroads of the Caribbean has made it a hub of trade and cultural exchange. St. Thomas was claimed by the Danish West India Company in 1672, and it quickly became one of the busiest ports in the West Indies. Ships from all over the world came to St. Thomas to trade goods, and the island became known as a center of luxury and excess. In 1801, St. Thomas was sold to the United States, and it became an important base for the US Navy during the 19th century. Today, St. Thomas is a popular tourist destination, and its rich history is evident in its many historic sites and buildings.

#5 Accessibility 

St. Thomas is quite accessible for tourists, as it is served by two airports and has a major port that receives cruise ships from all over the world. The island is also a popular destination for yacht charters, and there are many marinas where visitors can moor their boats. 

#6 Idyllic setting 

St. Thomas is an idyllic setting for a tropical vacation. The island boasts miles of sandy beaches, crystal-clear waters, and lush vegetation. There are also a number of historical and cultural attractions, including Fort Christian, the legislator’s building, and Magic Ice. Visitors can enjoy a variety of activities, such as swimming, snorkeling, fishing, sailing, and hiking. 

Read More 

Best virgin islands to visit in 2022

12 Best Snorkeling Spots in the Caribbean

St Croix vs St Thomas: Cons of St. Thomas Island

Like any island, there are some potential downsides to living on St. Thomas. Depending on your lifestyle and preferences, these may or may not be significant concerns for you. Here are a few things to consider before making the move to St. Thomas:

#1 Limited resources and services 

St. Thomas has limited resources and services compared to larger cities or mainland areas because it is an island. If you’re looking for a quiet, laid-back lifestyle, this might be a perfect fit for you. But if you’re used to having everything at your fingertips of city living, it might take some getting used to.

#2 Hurricane risk

St. Thomas is a hurricane-prone island in the Caribbean. The hurricane season typically runs from June to November, with the peak period occurring from August to October. In recent years, St. Thomas has been hit by hurricanes Irma, Maria, and Jose. As a result of these storms, the island has experienced significant damage to infrastructure and property. In addition, St. Thomas has a high risk of flooding due to its location in the storm surge zone. Storm surge is a wall of water that is pushed ashore by a hurricane’s winds. This can cause widespread flooding and damage to homes and businesses.

Hurricane Risk - St. Thomas

#3 Cost of Living

St. Thomas is a beautiful island destination, but it can be one of the most expensive places to vacation. The high cost of living on the island means that prices for food, lodging, and activities are all relatively high. And while there are ways to save money on vacation, such as staying in a less expensive hotel or eating at local restaurants, the overall cost of a St. Thomas vacation can still be quite high. For travelers on a budget, it may be worth considering alternative destinations that offer more value for your money. But for those who are willing to spend a bit extra, St. Thomas is still an incredible place to visit and enjoy all that it has to offer.

#4 Crowded 

During peak season, the island can be quite crowded. Visitors may find themselves competing for space on the beach or waiting in line for a table at their favorite restaurant. Despite the crowds, St. Thomas is still an excellent choice for a summer vacation. Just be sure to plan ahead and avoid the busiest times if you want to avoid the crowds.

St Croix vs St Thomas: Final Thought

So, which is the best island for vacation? The answer to that question really depends on what you are looking for in a vacation. If you want beautiful beaches, great shopping, and plenty of nightlife options, then St. Thomas is probably the better choice. However, if you are looking for a more relaxed and laid-back atmosphere with fewer crowds, then St. Croix may be a better fit for you. I hope this St. Croix vs St. Thomas debate was helpful for making your final decision. No matter which island you choose, we guarantee that you will have an amazing time sailing around the Caribbean on our yacht charter!


Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *